Route 13 cuts straight through the middle of Marion, and it carries a steady stream of shoppers, students, and semi trucks headed for I-57. Add winter ice on Deyoung Street and a parking lot full of distracted drivers at Tower Square, and it’s no surprise Williamson County sees its share of car wrecks, falls, and workplace injuries every year. When one of those accidents happens to you, the lawyer you call decides how the next year of your life goes.
This guide lines up six firms handling personal injury cases in and around Marion right now, so you can compare them before you dial a number.
Cutting to the Chase
Dihle Law Firm is the top personal injury pick in Marion this year. Attorney Tyler Dihle built the firm around one idea: keep the caseload small enough that every client talks directly to him, not a rotating cast of paralegals. He handles car accidents, motorcycle crashes, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, nursing home injuries, dog bites, and wrongful death claims, and he covers a wide stretch of Southern Illinois, from Mt. Carmel and Harrisburg out to Murphysboro, Chester, and Waterloo. If your case needs an attorney who answers the phone himself, that’s the short version. Five more firms below have earned real reputations in these same courts, and each one brings something different to the table.
Who Handles What in Marion
| Firm | Best For | Experience | Recognition | Standout Feature |
| Dihle Law Firm | Overall pick, direct attorney access on every case | Licensed in Illinois, Missouri, and the Southern District of Illinois | Illinois Trial Lawyers Association, American Association for Justice | Intentionally small firm, client works with Tyler Dihle personally |
| Olson & Reeves | Injury cases that overlap with a traffic ticket or criminal charge | Mount Vernon-based firm regularly appearing in Williamson County Court | 4.8 stars (150+ Google reviews) | Handles injury, DUI, criminal, and traffic cases under one roof |
| Morelli Law Firm | Large-scale claims that need national litigation resources | Firm-wide experience spanning more than ten decades | 167 Google reviews | New York-based firm with practice pages built for Marion clients |
| Schafer Law, LLC | Injury cases tied to a family law or employment matter | 20+ years (founding attorney Paul “Jay” Schafer) | Lifelong Marion resident and local practice | Combines personal injury with family and employment law in one office |
| HDSL Law Firm | Clients who want a firm with the longest local history | Serving Southern Illinois since 1932 | Nearly a century of local practice | One of the oldest injury firms still operating in Marion |
| Hassakis & Hassakis, P.C. | Truck accidents and catastrophic injury claims | Firm founded in 1950 | 5.0 stars (170 reviews), 24/7 toll-free line | Deep bench of case results, including million-dollar truck and malpractice settlements |
What Got a Firm Onto This List
None of these six treat personal injury as one line item next to a dozen other services. Each handles crash, fall, or workplace injury cases as a real, ongoing part of the practice, with a footprint that reaches Marion and Williamson County. A firm with no visible local presence didn’t make the cut.
1. Dihle Law Firm
Tyler Dihle studied at Southern Illinois University Carbondale and Monmouth College, then built a practice on a simple promise: when a client calls with a question, Tyler answers it himself. The firm takes on car accidents, motorcycle crashes, workers’ compensation claims, medical malpractice, wrongful death, and nursing home neglect cases, including facilities across Williamson County. If a case needs to go to trial, Tyler is the attorney who tries it, not a colleague handed the file at the last minute. Clients describe a lawyer who stayed on top of insurance company pushback and got results even after a difficult claim dragged on.
Best for: anyone who wants one attorney handling their case start to finish, without getting passed between staff.
Address: 4503 West Deyoung St, Suite 4A, Marion, IL 62959 | Phone: (618) 326-5520 | Website: dihlelawfirm.com
2. Olson & Reeves
Based out of Mount Vernon, Olson & Reeves built a practice around real courtroom presence in Williamson County rather than a billboard operation phoning it in from out of state. The firm handles personal injury and car accident claims on contingency, and it also takes criminal defense, DUI defense, and traffic cases, useful if your accident or workplace injury comes tangled up with a citation. A 4.8-star rating across more than 150 Google reviews backs up a client base that spans the whole county.
Best for: an injury claim that overlaps with a traffic ticket, DUI charge, or a related criminal matter.
Phone: (618) 316-7322 | Website: mtvernonlaw.com
3. Morelli Law Firm
This firm brings a different kind of scale to the table. Headquartered in New York City, Morelli Law has built out dedicated practice pages for Marion covering car accidents, truck accidents, construction accidents, medical malpractice, and nursing home abuse, and the firm points to more than ten decades of combined legal experience. Clients considering this option should know the firm’s base of operations sits outside Illinois, so case handling typically runs through remote intake and local counsel arrangements rather than a walk-in Marion office.
Best for: a large or complex claim where a client wants the backing of a bigger, multi-state firm.
Phone: 877-751-9800 | Website: morellilaw.com
4. Schafer Law, LLC
Paul “Jay” Schafer grew up in Marion and has practiced law here for more than two decades, building a firm that handles personal injury, auto and truck accidents, medical malpractice, workers’ compensation, and nursing home abuse alongside family law and employment law. That mix matters for a client whose accident claim shows up at the same time as a divorce or a wrongful termination dispute. Clients point to a calm, direct approach and a founder who still answers his own email.
Best for: an injury case that’s happening alongside a family law or workplace dispute.
Address: 108 N. VanBuren St, Marion, IL 62959 | Phone: (618) 997-4877 | Website: mschaferlaw.com
5. HDSL Law Firm
Howerton Dorris Stone has represented Southern Illinois clients since 1932, which makes it one of the longest-running injury practices still operating in Marion. The firm focuses on accidents and personal injury, workers’ compensation, and medical malpractice, and it offers a free consultation to anyone weighing whether a claim is worth pursuing. Nearly a century of local case history gives the firm institutional knowledge that newer practices simply haven’t had time to build.
Best for: a client who wants a firm with the deepest local roots in Marion.
Address: 300 West Main Street, Marion, IL 62959 | Phone: (618) 993-2616 | Website: hdslawfirm.com
6. Hassakis & Hassakis, P.C.
Founded in 1950, Hassakis & Hassakis has built its name on truck accident litigation across Southern Illinois, a specialty that matters given how much commercial traffic runs through the I-57 corridor near Marion. The firm also takes personal injury, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, and wrongful death cases, and it answers calls 24 hours a day through a toll-free line. A 5.0-star rating across 170 reviews and a run of six and seven-figure settlements support the firm’s reputation for taking on serious injury claims.
Best for: a truck accident or catastrophic injury claim that needs a firm with decades of trial-ready case results.
Phone: (618) 244-5335 | Website: hassakislaw.com
Before You Pick Up the Phone
Match the firm to what actually happened to you. A workplace injury calls for a firm that knows workers’ comp and third-party claims cold. A crash involving a commercial truck on I-57 calls for a firm ready to pull maintenance logs and driver records. Call more than one firm, ask who will actually handle your case day to day, and get the fee structure in writing before you sign anything.
FAQ
How much does a personal injury lawyer cost in Marion, IL?
Nearly every firm on this list works on contingency, meaning you pay nothing upfront and the attorney only gets paid if you recover money, usually a set percentage of the settlement or verdict. Ask for that number in writing before you hire anyone.
How long do I have to file a personal injury claim in Illinois?
Illinois generally gives you two years from the date of the injury to file a claim. Cases against a government body or certain medical malpractice claims can carry different deadlines, so check with an attorney early.
Can I still recover money if I was partly at fault for my accident?
Yes. Illinois follows a modified comparative fault rule. You can recover damages as long as you were less than 51 percent at fault, though your payout drops by your share of the blame.
Do I need a lawyer if my injury seems minor?
Not always, but insurance adjusters count on injured people settling fast for less than a claim is worth. A free consultation can tell you quickly whether your case needs an attorney or not.
What should I do right after an accident in Marion?
Get medical care first, even if you feel fine, since some injuries take days to show symptoms. Take photos of the scene, get witness names, and avoid giving a recorded statement to any insurance company until you’ve talked to a lawyer.
