If you shop for groceries often, you may have noticed peanut butter missing or costing more than usual at times. Peanut butter shortages come up every few years, affecting families, small businesses, and anyone who relies on this staple. Understanding the real causes behind these shortages—and what may happen next—will help you set expectations for your budget and supply planning.
In this article, you’ll see why peanut butter sometimes vanishes from the shelves, what’s driving current and future shortages, and how the industry responds. We’ll keep it straightforward and clear, so you can decide how best to prepare your household or business for these supply swings.
Recent Shortages and Causes
1. The 2022 Jif Peanut Butter Recall
One major reason for recent shortages was the 2022 recall of Jif peanut butter. Jif is the top-selling peanut butter brand in the U.S., and the recall pulled millions of jars from stores across the country due to salmonella concerns. If you were trying to buy peanut butter that summer, you likely saw empty shelves or strict buying limits.
The recall came at a tough time—COVID-era disruptions had already slowed production and shipping for many food products. This combination led to sudden supply gaps, sending shoppers to alternative brands or private labels, which then ran low as well. Many families started stocking up, worrying another shortage was around the corner. When a best-selling product like Jif goes off the market, suppliers and retailers struggle to keep up with sudden shifts in demand, and market prices jump as a result.
2. Global Market Challenges—2024 to 2025
Looking ahead, peanut butter availability depends not just on the local U.S. crop, but on global peanut production, especially in key exporter countries. For the 2024-2025 cycle, Argentina—a major peanut grower—faced severe crop problems. Droughts and poor growing conditions meant a far smaller harvest. Countries that typically rely on cheap imports from Argentina, including much of Europe and Asia, have had to look elsewhere.
Efforts to recover supply from Brazil and the U.S. haven’t solved the issue. Brazil’s peanut production is growing but lacks the established quality and volume. U.S. producers, facing their own harvest troubles, have little surplus to export. These struggles have driven up global peanut prices. For buyers, this means higher costs for everyone in the supply chain; peanut butter makers must choose between shrinking their margins or raising shelf prices.
3. U.S. Peanut Harvest Declines
In the past year, peanut production in the U.S. dropped by roughly 13%, reaching its smallest yield since 2006. If you own a bakery, candy shop, or business that uses peanut butter, you may have had to pay more, switch suppliers, or limit product offerings.
This decline happened for several reasons. Hot, dry weather in major peanut-growing regions reduced crop yields. At the same time, many farmers shifted acreage to cotton and other, more profitable crops as peanut prices initially lagged behind. Fewer planted acres plus tough weather equals tighter supply. Peanut processors responded by increasing prices, which, as you might have noticed, has become standard at the grocery store.
Historical Context
Shortages of peanut butter and spikes in prices aren’t new. In 1980, for example, the U.S. went through a well-known “peanut butter crisis.” A poor harvest that year—combined with strong consumer demand—sent prices soaring. Many brands shrank jar sizes or temporarily disappeared from stores.
Other short-term shortages have cropped up over the decades, and the pattern is often similar. As peanut butter is a staple in many U.S. households and schools, changes in price or availability create strong reactions. Because demand doesn’t drop much, even when prices go up (a concept called inelastic demand), small changes in the peanut or peanut butter supply have a big effect on the market.
Current Market Outlook
You might wonder if the future will bring steadier supply or if prices will ease soon. According to recent forecasts, the global peanut butter market is projected to grow—from about $5.7 billion in 2025 to over $8.3 billion by 2035. Health trends, such as people wanting more plant-based protein, are a driving force, especially as new buyers in developing countries increase their consumption.
That said, recent production and transportation challenges are likely to cause continued bumps in the road. If weather remains unreliable in key peanut-producing countries, or if new contamination issues occur, you can expect further price volatility. For small food businesses, having backup suppliers and clear communication with distributors will remain key steps to managing the risk of outages.
Key Factors Driving Shortages
When understanding the peanut butter supply chain, several areas matter more than most people realize:
Poor Harvests and Weather Problems
Unfavorable weather—especially drought or excessive heat—can drastically shrink peanut harvests. Because peanuts are sensitive to soil and rain patterns, changes even in one region, such as the Southeast U.S. or central Argentina, have ripple effects worldwide. Farmers often can’t recover lost yields until the next planting year. If you’re budgeting for business, account for the possibility of sharp price swings due to weather.
Recalls and Contamination Incidents
A single recall, like the 2022 Jif incident, can pull millions of jars off shelves in days. Not only does this disrupt your grocery list, but it puts stress on smaller brands, who often don’t have the capacity to ramp up production quickly. Recalls also raise concerns about food safety, which, in turn, may motivate consumers to stockpile trusted alternatives.
Inflexible Supply Chains and Strategic Reserves
Unlike corn or wheat, peanuts aren’t widely stockpiled in large reserves. Processing and packaging peanut butter takes time, and there aren’t many factories that can double their capacity on short notice. When demand suddenly spikes, as during a recall or poor harvest, supply chains don’t have much cushion. This rigidity means outages last longer and prices climb faster.
Increased Consumer Demand and Stockpiling
Peanut butter is a non-perishable, high-protein food that’s easy to store, so when people worry about shortages, they’re likely to buy extra packs. This “just in case” buying behavior is common anytime there’s news of a recall or empty shelves. If you run a small store, try to watch buying trends and set fair limits early when shortages pop up, so more customers can get their share.
Competition for Agricultural Land and Rising Input Costs
Growing peanuts requires dedicated acreage and long-term soil management. If prices for other crops, like cotton or soybeans, rise, farmers sometimes reduce peanut planting. Fuel, fertilizer, and labor costs also influence how much peanut farmers can afford to invest each year. Over time, these changing costs are passed on to processors, retailers, and you as the end consumer.
Practical Outlook and How to Prepare
Given all these factors, recurring supply vulnerabilities are likely to stick around, at least for the foreseeable future. For consumers, this means you may see price hikes—or temporary out-of-stocks—on peanut butter, especially after major recalls or weather events. For small businesses, keeping communication open with multiple suppliers, and planning for short-term substitutes when needed, will help keep your business running.
It is vital to avoid panic-buying, as this can worsen supply shortages for everyone. If you are supplying food to schools or other institutions, review your contracts and discuss supply chain risks with your vendors. Once you have done so, keep documentation of your supplier communications and revisit them at least annually, or whenever a major shortage is announced.
Depending on your role, you may want to subscribe to market updates from trade sources, or join local business groups, to stay ahead of supply news. Another area to consider is exploring alternatives—such as different nut or seed butters—if peanut availability becomes unreliable.
For entrepreneurs and food retailers, maintaining transparency in your pricing and sourcing is a best practice. Customers appreciate knowing why costs rise or why you’re limiting purchases. Keeping a simple FAQ or signage at your place of business helps everyone plan accordingly.
Looking long-term, the ongoing popularity of peanut butter means that demand will remain high. However, factors like weather disruptions, global supply chain challenges, and price pressures aren’t likely to disappear anytime soon. Stay alert for global harvest updates and be prepared for potential lulls in supply.
If you’re running a business and want more insights into managing production risks during food shortages, sites like Redwire Business offer helpful guides for navigating these cycles.
Conclusion
Peanut butter shortages have happened before and will likely appear again, driven by a mix of weather problems, production disruptions, and global competition for land and resources. While the industry usually recovers within a season or two, the resulting price spikes and empty shelves can catch both consumers and business owners off guard.
Be sure to monitor supply trends, keep smart reserves but avoid over-purchasing, and stay in touch with your suppliers or retailers. By understanding the drivers of these shortages, you can better plan—whether you’re stocking your pantry or keeping your shop’s shelves full. As always, reviewing sourcing options and staying flexible is your best approach for the unpredictable peanut butter market ahead.
Also Read:
